2011 SAG Awards Smokin’ eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and I’m (mostly) impressed

Natalie Portman 2011 SAG Awards 2 Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Here we go again! Another Sunday in January, another awards show for our celebrity-gawking pleasure: this time, the SAG (Screen Actors Guild) Awards, held yesterday in LA.

At the SAGs, the vibe, and therefore the fashion, is a little more casual than the Globes and the Oscars. So maybe that’s why—surprise!—I have far more praise to dole out today instead of my usual “constructive criticism.”

No really. Maybe it’s because there’s less pressure for the SAGs than the Globes—or maybe all the celebrity hair and makeup artists just returned from a lengthy hiatus?—but for the most part, everybody looked pretty pulled together. And I’m LOVING that a few of ‘em even busted out some of my fave beauty trends: hot pink lips (on Claire Danes and Amber Riley) and Gucci Westman-style black eyeliner (on Kate Mara).

So! Let’s take a look at the greatest hits (and a few rare misses) of the night…

BEST LOOSE WAVES: A tie between Mila Kunis

Mila Kunis 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

…and Hilary Swank

Hilary Swank 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Does Mila Kunis ever look bad? I really don’t think so. Last night, she was sporting what one might call her “signature eye”—a triumph of brown shadows and liner that defines without overpowering. Great brows, and then… The Hair. A really splendid (read: sexy but just slightly imperfect) execution of flat iron waves here. Hilary rocked the same look, but in a shorter length. Now THIS is the hairstyle that Sofia Vergara and Angelina Jolie should have channeled at the Globes.

BEST BLUSH: Natalie Portman

Natalie Portman 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

I’m a blush lover. I can’t help it. I just think everyone looks prettier, healthier, BETTER, with rosy cheeks. Not sure if Nat’s flush comes from a compact or the bébé in her tummy, but either way, it looks fab. (So does the $2 million of Tiffany jewelry.) Her hair, on the other hand, could use less gel. Looks a bit crunchy on top there!

SULTRIEST EYE MAKEUP: Christina Hendricks

Christina Hendricks 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Yay! After a disappointing ‘do at the Globes (her voluminous red hair fought with the voluminous red shoulder of her dress), my girl Christina made a red carpet comeback. (At least from the neck up—didn’t love the dress all that much.) But how deliciously sex kitten-ish is she with these smoky eyes? Paired with the pale pink gloss, they set off her creamy, porcelain skin to perfection. The hair is good too: softly curled but not too “done.”

MOST IMPROVED: Lea Michele

Lea Michele 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Lea Michele should always dress this way. As in: sexy ’70s girl, not a poufy pink princess like she was at the Globes. (Nobody wants a repeat of Gwyneth Paltrow’s 1999 Oscars look.) I REALLY like her hair here: like Mila’s and Hilary’s, it’s been waved with a flat iron, but the ends were left straight and it has tons of (slightly messy) volume. Now if only the girl could quit it with the fakey air kiss blowing.

SLEEKEST PONYTAIL: Amy Adams

Amy Adams 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Not too many people can pull off a) a body-con white dress and b) a super-slick high ponytail. So props to Amy Adams, because I think she looks great. Wearing tons of makeup with this would’ve been the absolute wrong move, so I’m super-happy that she went for a fresh face. Bonus points for the fuller brows too.

BEST BRIGHT LIP: A three-way tie between Claire Danes

Claire Danes 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Amber Riley

Amber Riley 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

…and Dianna Agron

Diana Agron 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Oh. Mah. Gawd. I’m just delighted to see all of these pink lips in varying shades of brightness. Claire obviously pulled out all the stops with a fluoro hot pink. Amber’s shade was equally bright, while Dianna went for a muted pink that worked surprisingly well with her brown smokies (because a nude lip would’ve been WAY predictable).

BEST SOFT LIP: Rosario Dawson

Rosario Dawson 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Meanwhile, Rosario bucked the bright lip trend by going with a soft peach (and not much on the eyes either). I admire how good she looks with not much makeup, but just wondering if this is a bit too casual?

BEST BROWS: Angie Harmon

Angie Harmon 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Not a fan of the dress choice, or even the super-slick hair on her. (Again, it’s too sweet, too young, too Gwyneth Paltrow circa 1999. Also: are you seeing a lighter-coloured regrowth at her part line?) But there is redemption: Angie has one of the best pairs of brows in the biz.

BEST SLICKED-BACK ‘DO: Julianna Margulies

Julianna Margulies 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Okay, so I didn’t love the tight-to-the-head, super-slicked hair on Angie. But on Julianna? Maybe it’s the shape of her face (more round), maybe it’s the earrings, or maybe it’s just her big, genuine smile… I don’t know, but I actually like this.

BEST BLAST FROM THE PAST: Winona Ryder

Winona Ryder 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Like Alyssa Milano, Winona is one of those stars who just doesn’t seem to age. Still looks good, no? If any work has been done, it’s been with an expert hand. Like we saw at Valentino the other day, the plummy eye makeup is terrifically flattering. But why—WHY?—do her eyes have the look of a crazy person? Is it just me?

MOST AGE-APPROPRIATE: Hailee Steinfeld

Hailee Steinfeld 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Seeing girls who aren’t yet old enough to drive/drink/vote wearing layers and layers of heavy makeup is reeeeeeally off-putting. (Think Miley Cyrus back in the day. Or, uh, last week. Whichever.) So it’s a pleasure to see Hailee here—who is a wee 14 years old—wearing nothing but tinted lip gloss and perhaps a bit of mascara. Sweet.

And here’s where things start to go south…

WORST HAIR ACCESSORY (BUT POSSIBLY THE PRETTIEST MAKEUP): Kate Mara

Kate Mara 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Kate Mara is a doll, an absolute doll. Gorgeous red hair, a peaches ‘n cream complexion and wow, I think she even watched my vid with Gucci Westman on how to DIY black eyeliner. Everything was so perfect here, which is why the addition of that headband (is it made of feathers?) is such a crime. Take. It. Off.

MOST MAN-REPELLING HAIR: January Jones

January Jones 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Oh January, you’re so hit and miss. I know I told you that I love you best when you do the retro thing, but sometimes you go too far with it. This hair, for example. Sure, you could call it elegant, but I would also call it man-repelling. Also? I know you’re trying to copy ScarJo with the gold eyeshadow at the inner corners of your eyes. But with everything else so formal, it ain’t workin’.

ODDEST LIPSTICK: Sofia Vergara

Sofia Vergara 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

I don’t know why, but Sofia Vergara’s lipstick continues to bother me. I read a story about her recently where she’s quoted as saying that she always wears lipstick, never gloss—I think because she feels like she needs to be more womanly what with her va-va-voom type of figure. And I’m okay with that. I just feel like her choices could be a bit more modern in both texture and colour. Are you with me? (Then again, based on the cut of her dress, I doubt too many people were looking at her face…)

MOST IN NEED OF SOME BLUSH (AND A HAIRBRUSH): Kim Kardashian

Kim Kardashian 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

I feel like we should give Kim a few points here for taking our concerns on board and going with a slightly lighter makeup job here. Sure, the base is still thick, and the gloss is still goopy, and don’t even get me started on those spidery eyelashes—but at least we don’t have a smoky eye or heavily contoured cheek to contend with on top of all that. Still, if anyone could use some blush, it’s this woman. Also hair serum.

MOST FRUMPY: Jenna Fischer

Jenna Fischer 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Casting Jenna Fischer in The Office was genius, because she has the rare talent of ALWAYS LOOKING LIKE AN UNHAPPY OFFICE WORKER. Even on the red carpet. No offense to office workers everywhere, but come on! A low pony, boring makeup and an ill-fitting grey dress? Zzzzzzzzzzz.

REPEAT EYEBROW OFFENDER: Julia Stiles

Julia Stiles 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Not much to add to my previous rant about Julia Stiles’ eyebrow colour. They are still too light—in fact, greyish—and really ruining her whole look.

WORST INNER-EYE HIGHLIGHTER: Eva Longoria

Eva Longoria 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

She’s cut from the same cloth as Jennifer Lopez, this one. But while J. Lo’s white highlighter transgression occurred on the brow bone, Eva’s is happening at the inner corners of the eyes. I’m not opposed to a bit of highlight work, but this is just TOO MUCH. PS: Kim Kardashian called and she wants her eyelashes back.

WORST SMOKIES: Jennifer Lawrence

Jennifer Lawrence 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Loved the dress, but it’s time to fire your makeup artist, Jen. This was a smoky eye #fail of the worst kind (and by that I mean the overdone, heavy-handed kind). Find out who did Christina Hendricks’ (above) and copy her. Always.

MOST MEH: Nicole Kidman

Nicole Kidman 2011 SAG Awards Smokin eyes! Pink lips! Sexy hair! The celebs busted out their best beauty looks for the 2011 SAG Awards and Im (mostly) impressed

Nic’s red carpet glory days are over. She looks decent, sure, but the hair is boring and so is the makeup, and I’m extremely bothered by the fact that she’s wearing a necklace with that high neckline.

So tell me—

Who do YOU think looked the best at the SAG Awards?
Who needs a new makeup artist and/or hairstylist?
Do you agree that the celebs stepped it up, beauty-wise, for this show? It’s SO nice of them to take our feedback to heart, isn’t it?

5 Comments

Anya
Wednesday, February 2/2011 at 12:04 pm

This year is all about Natalie. Gorgeous!

Reply

Gimped
Wednesday, February 2/2011 at 4:24 pm

Mila Kunis is my fave I think. MAN did she ever get gorgeous after her days in Pointe Place – did you see her on the cover of Cosmo?? Not a huge fan of her dress but her face is KILLER! The dress wasn’t a total fail, but it was too loud for my taste. I’d like to see her in something lacy and super femme. And no, Mila never looks bad. I hate her, too, Michelle.

Sofia Vergara’s dress was GORGEOUS!! That blue was just stunning!! BUT, I think she was a little too busty for it – her figure looked … weird. Mila I think could have rocked the hell out it. Anyway, her dress was so gorg I never really paid attention to her makeup. It’s not bad … but doesn’t stand up to her awesome gown :)

Voting Angie Harmon your best brows made me smile – my brows are very similar to that!! Yay, I’m doing something right!!!

BTW, Nicole Kidman … looks REALLY old in that photo.

Reply

Comment Avatar Michelle Villett
Wednesday, March 16/2011 at 5:30 pm

Oh wowww – I didn’t see that Cosmo cover, but she looks incredible. So seksi, who knew?

Awesome about your brows, by the way. Partly genetic, partly the Benefit brow bar? :-)

Reply

Gimped
Friday, March 18/2011 at 9:05 am

TOTALLY Brow Bar. Genetics have nothing to do with it. Lol!!

Reply

Aly
Tuesday, November 1/2011 at 10:20 am

I think I’ve figured out why Winona has crazy eyes. If you look closely at the curvature of her eyes, you can see that they bulge considerably more than the average eye would. She must have poor eyesight – the muscles of the eye begin to deform the eye shape and either flatten or lengthen the eye. In her case, they’ve been lengthened and I think it’s because she is short sighted (can’t remember which one it is).

Reply

Leave a Comment