Is expensive nail polish worth the money? Here’s when to save and when to splurge!

Dior - Spring 2012 nails

When you’re looking for a new and fresh nail polish colour to buy, is it worth dishing out the big bucks? Or are there cheaper look-a-likes that get the job done just as well, if not better?

I’ve always kind of wondered this. As a student, I’m always looking out for great deals. So after a six-year hiatus from science class, I did the only kind of science experiment I know how to do: a beauty one! I tested some higher-end brands against some drugstore versions of nail polish colours that are trending right now. Read on to find out where you can save, and where you can splurge…

Magnetic Polishes

Magnetic polish is one of the newest crazes—and it involves very little effort from the person applying it. If you are into the idea of nail art, but feel you lack the artsy skill to pull it off, magnetic polish is for you!

For anyone who doesn’t know how it works:
1. Paint all your nails with a first coat.
2. Apply a thick second coat to each nail.
3. Right away, take the magnet—which comes attached to the neck of the bottle—and hold it over each nail for about 10 seconds. (It’s probably best to paint your nails and then apply the magnet one at a time, since speed is of the essence!)
4. MAGNET MAGIC!

I tested these two brands:

SplurgeNails Inc. Magnetic Polish in Soho ($18)
SaveSally Hansen Magnetic Nail Color in Graphite Gravity ($9.99 from Well.ca—free shipping in Canada with no minimum purchase!)

magnetic polish Is expensive nail polish worth the money? Heres when to save and when to splurge!

I think it’s obvious that the actual magnetic effect shows up much better with the Nails Inc. polish. The Sally Hansen has a more subtle effect. Unfortunately, Sally started to frustrate me because I would hold the magnet over the nail for the allotted 10 seconds suggested, and nothing would happen. It was easily fixable… I just painted on another layer and tried again. But that frustration led me to my decision…

Verdict: Worth the splurge!

Pro tip: Shut the bottle and shake it before you start your second hand, in order to re-ignite the magnetic “stuff” in the bottle. I found that if I didn’t, the effect became less and less visible with every finger.

Mint Green Nail Polish

If you’ve tried to apply a light colour before, you know: they’re extremely difficult to apply. I will admit it, I am a self-proclaimed sheer-hater. One of my pet peeves is un-polished (Is that a word? Okay, it is now) nails, so I like my polish to be opaque.

I tested these two brands:

SplurgeOPI Nail Polish in Gargantuan Green Grape ($11)
SaveMaybelline New York Color Show Nail Polish in Green With Envy ($4)

mint green polish Is expensive nail polish worth the money? Heres when to save and when to splurge!

Some brands, like Sally Hansen, Avon and now Maybelline New York, hold amazing track records with me for creating a polish formula that is opaque even though the colour is extremely light.

On the opposite end of the spectrum, sometimes OPI makes it so hard for me to get an opaque colour with their lighter polishes. You can probably tell in the picture above, the OPI is still a little bit sheer, even after the three coats I applied! Granted, I love OPI for their darker shades. However, when it comes to mint green… Maybelline’s new polish line Color Show has my heart. Their mint green, Green with Envy, gave me full coverage in one layer!

Verdict: Save your $$$ and hit up your local drugstore.

Plum Nail Polish

I love when it’s that time in the year, where we swap out the summer neons and brights for the fall jewel tones. Plum seems to be on its way in as a fall trend. If you’re diggin’ this newly popular colour (like I am), and thinking of investing lots of $$$ in a new polish… listen up!

Here’s what I tested:

SplurgeSephora by OPI Nail Colour in Meet for Drinks ($12)
SaveSally Hansen Hard as Nails Xtreme Wear Nail Color in Flirt ($3.49 from Well.ca—free shipping in Canada with no minimum purchase!)

plum polish Is expensive nail polish worth the money? Heres when to save and when to splurge!

The Sally Hansen is a teeny bit darker, but still has that extra “oomph” from the subtle shimmer like the more expensive Plum from Sephora by OPI. Let’s be honest… they are almost virtually the same. Also, points go to Sally Hansen for the brush: it is much thicker than the Sephora by OPI brushes, and therefore much more user (ahem: amateur applicator) friendly.

Verdict: Worth saving your $$$.

Shatter/crackle nail polish

While I kind of think this trend is old news (we’re all free-handing nail art now, don’t you know?!), it’s still worth a look. OPI came out with the original Black Shatter in January 2011, and from there, lots of other nail polish brands followed suit with their own versions.

This isn’t quite a save versus splurge, since both prices are the same, but OPI is a salon brand whereas Nicole by OPI is at Walmart.

Splurge: OPI Nail Polish in Turquoise Shatter/Red Shatter ($11)
Save: Nicole by OPI Texture Coat in Turquoise Texture/Red Texture ($11)

turquoise shatter Is expensive nail polish worth the money? Heres when to save and when to splurge!

red shatter Is expensive nail polish worth the money? Heres when to save and when to splurge!

Both OPI’s and Nicole by OPI’s turquoise and red look the same. However, OPI has a thicker formula, which makes for better coverage and a more intense colour. But the real question is: did the salon brand (OPI) shatter my world? (Hehe—see what I did there?!)

The answer: not really. The OPI has fewer, more exaggerated cracks, which I personally prefer. In comparison, the Nicole by OPI has lots of thin slivers… it almost resembles a wooden effect, dontchyathink?!

Verdict: Personally, worth going for the salon version! But it depends on your taste—that’s only if you want the true shattered mirror/glass effect. For a more subtle crackle, Nicole by OPI definitely gets the job done. See for yourself!

Pro tip #1: When the OPI Shatter polishes go forgotten and sit on your shelf for a few months, they become extremely clumpy and therefore don’t shatter as well as a fresh bottle. Try to remember to give it a stir… it helps a lot. Learned that the hard way.

Pro tip #2: Don’t use a coloured shatter or crackle polish that is similar to the base colour you applied. Instead of creating a super-funky effect, it just looks like extremely lumpy polish application.

As a nail polish addict, I dabble in all sorts of nail polish brands ranging from $1.99 to $25. While it is exciting to splurge on an unique and unparalleled colour, it is nice to know that there are great—if not better—options for us folk who can’t always drop the big bucks for something that chips away after a week or so anyway!

Rikki Ciminsky is a student at Ryerson University in Toronto. Follow her on Twitter: @rikki_see.

Tell us:

How much do you like to spend on nail polish, and how often do you buy it?
Which brands, colours or textures are worth the splurge?
Which drugstore nail polishes do you swear by?

8 Comments

KAPP
Tuesday, October 9/2012 at 2:48 pm

any idea what color and brand the model in the first pic is wearing…that color is so fabulous

Reply

Comment Avatar Michelle Villett
Tuesday, October 9/2012 at 5:56 pm

That pic’s from the Dior spring couture show, so I’m almost certain it’s a Dior nail lacquer. Of the lineup here looks like it could be Poison or Purple Revolution…

http://www.dior.com/beauty/int/en/makeup/nails/nail_lacquers/lnaillacquers.html

Reply

Harpreet
Wednesday, October 10/2012 at 4:28 pm

Thanks for this post, so helpful!

Reply

Leah
Thursday, October 11/2012 at 1:25 am

I can’t believe how cheap nail polish is in Canada!! In Australia the standard price for a Revlon/Maybeline or similar nail polish is about $15! OPI is $20 per bottle and Chanel etc are around $40-50. We are getting ripped off!

Reply

Comment Avatar Michelle Villett
Thursday, October 11/2012 at 8:53 pm

OMG really? That’s criminal! You need to take a beauty trip to North America and load up! Are the local brands there just as expensive?

Reply

Leah
Friday, October 12/2012 at 1:58 am

Yes! You can barely get a nail polish for under $13, unless they are the really crappy ones from $2 shops. I definitely want to shop at sephora one day – it sounds amazing and so cheap!

Reply

Reem
Thursday, October 11/2012 at 2:30 am

Nicole by OPI has a mint green that’s called ‘my lifesaver’. It’s very similar to the essie and maybelline one you’ve swatched above, I love using it in the summer time!

Reply

Brittany
Sunday, February 3/2013 at 2:17 pm

I use Sally Hansen shatter polishes. They give the exact same look as OPI. I personally have never liked Nicole by OPI, it dries too slow.

Reply

Leave a Comment