Is there any beauty product with a higher level of dissatisfaction than lip balm?
I've heard from dozens of readers complaining about their dry, chapped, even CRACKING lips—and how no lip balm ever seems to cure the problem.
Here's a recent email from my inbox:
Any ideas for a great lip balm? My lips are always chapped! I do live in a dry area. I also seem to lick my lips, which I'm trying hard to stop. I have installed a humidifier in my home that is on constantly. I apply lip ointment several times a day. My toothpaste does not have any SLS in it. Only my bottom lip appears to struggle. I use squalane on them, still no help! I read the new matte Dior Lip Glow doesn't work well on dry lips, which really bums me out. I figured you might have other ideas! — Kathryn
I, too, have struggled with chronically dry lips. But I've finally figured out what to use—and what to avoid.
That's right. It's just as important to STOP using products with ingredients that cause chapping, as it is to START using treatments that will truly heal your lips.
In this article, you will learn:
- Why most lip balms only exacerbate the problem
- Which ingredients can keep your lips dry and chapped
- My three favourite healing ingredients to look for
- Which products contain them!
Why Most Lip Balms Don't Work
There are three reasons why most lip balms on the market fail to actually fix chapped lips.
Usually, these products contain:
Anything that irritates your lips can lead to dryness, peeling and chapping.
This is why you may not see an improvement despite always re-applying lip balm—it's because your lips are in contact with the irritant over and over again!
Some of the most common potential irritants in lip balms include:
- Essential oils
- Colour pigments
- Chemical sunscreen ingredients
Of course, you'll also find these things in other lip products, such as lipsticks, lip gloss, etc. So that Dior Lip Glow Kathryn mentioned? It looks amazing on the lips, but is not something I would recommend to heal chapping.
What you might not know is that even natural oils and waxes can be problematic because of allergic reactions.
Some potential allergens that you'll often see in lip balms (and other lip products) are:
- Vitamin E
- Castor oil
- Lanolin (although medical grade may be okay)
I suspect vitamin E is one of the biggest offenders here, particularly its synthetic form, tocopheryl acetate. (On labels, vitamin E is listed as tocopherol or tocopheryl acetate.) In this study, one third of patients developed contact dermatitis from vitamin E! I suspect this may have been a factor in the eos lawsuit, as continued use by an allergic person could definitely lead to the rashes and blisters that people reported.
Occlusives are ingredients that form a surface barrier on the lips, such as:
- Mineral oil
- Hydrogenated polyisobutene
Now, I'm not saying these are ALL bad, in a lip product. Their barrier qualities can help protect the lips and seal in moisture.
But they're not actually delivering moisture to the area. So they won't heal existing chapping.
You also have to be careful when they're combined with other ingredients, because they may be sealing in irritants or allergens.
The Best Treatments for Dry, Chapped Lips
So what do you want instead?
Emollients are softening, hydrating ingredients that absorb well into the skin, where they fill in cracks and prevent moisture loss.
The best emollients are natural oils and butters. I suggest using them in their pure form, rather than in combination with other ingredients. Since the lip area is so sensitive, it's better to use as few ingredients as possible in order to minimize the risk of irritation or an allergic reaction.
Here are the three emollient treatments that have worked best for me:
Lanolin is a wax found on the wool of sheep that has a similar molecular structure to human sebum, making it one of the most powerful moisturizers available to us. (It's also cruelty-free.)
But wait—didn't I just say that lanolin is a potential allergen?
Yes, it definitely can be. But if you're NOT allergic, its emollient and semi-occlusive properties make it a fantastic ingredient for healing dry, chapped lips.
There are also different grades of lanolin, and a medical-grade lanolin is much less likely to cause an issue. This study found that Medilan, an "an ultra-purified, hypoallergenic, medical-grade lanolin" caused "almost zero sensitization."
Now, we can't buy Medilan directly, since they're just a raw materials supplier. But there are a few companies that do use medical-grade lanolin, which is colourless and odourless, and has all the harmful elements filtered out.
For example, Lanolips' lanolin goes through a patented cleansing process that leaves it with fewer than three parts of impurities per MILLION!
Best Medical-Grade Lanolin Treatments
- Lanolips Multipurpose Superbalm: This ultra-pure lanolin has a thick, dense texture, gives a glossy finish, and is long-lasting. Find it in Canada here!
- Australian Golden Lanolin Lip Balm: This medical-grade lanolin comes in a tin, if you prefer that format.
- Superlan Ultra Pure Medical Grade Lanolin for Chapped Lips: A tube of medical-grade lanolin combined with jojoba oil.
- Dr. Lipp Original Nipple Balm for Lips: Also in a tube, this is 100 percent lanolin, but they don't disclose whether it's medical-grade. If you're concerned, you could always go with an actual nipple balm instead, such as...
- Lansinoh HPA Lanolin: Technically a breastfeeding balm, and you may not want to pull this out of your purse... but there's no reason you couldn't use it on your lips!
- Medela Tender Care Lanolin: Ditto for this one; besides lanolin, it has two other non-allergenic ingredients for a thinner texture.
Quelle surprise, I'm talking about squalane oil again!
Even though it's not technically sold as a lip treatment (YET), squalane is one of my favourite new discoveries not just for the face, but also for dry lips.
Squalane is the saturated form of squalene, an oil naturally produced by the human body that keeps our skin moisturized and protected. Although it can be derived from shark liver (which is NOT cruelty-free!), most beauty companies now source it from olives or sugarcane. If the label doesn't specify, make sure to ask where it came from!
Squalane is ideal for healing chapped skin because it has a finer texture than other oils, meaning it penetrates incredibly well (much more so than coconut oil, for example).
It's also super-stable (so it will last forever) and non-irritating. You can read more about squalane's many benefits over here.
Related: Why Squalane Is the Best Face Oil
Because it doesn’t form as much of a barrier, you may wish to layer squalane underneath a more occlusive product, especially if you're outside in harsh conditions.
The only downside? To date, I've only seen squalane in 30 mL/1 oz. glass bottles. Somebody needs to make it in a rollerball format!
Best Squalane Lip Treatments
- The Ordinary 100% Plant-Derived Squalane: A super-affordable squalane derived from plants.
- Timeless Squalane Oil: Another budget choice, from olives, although this is a bigger bottle. (Find the smaller size here.)
- Indie Lee Squalane Facial Oil: A high-quality squalane derived from olives.
- Peter Thomas Roth Oilless Oil Purified Squalane Treatment: Also great quality, this one is sourced from sugarcane.
- Mullein & Sparrow Pure Series Squalane Oil: Unlike the others, which come with droppers, this olive-sourced squalane features a pump secured with a plastic cap.
- Olivarrier Fluid Oil Squalane: An extra-hydrating K-beauty option derived from olives.
Last but not least, there's shea butter.
This is another stable fat with excellent moisturizing properties. Extracted from the fat of the African shea tree, it remains solid at room temperature—which can be more convenient for a lip balm if you're on the go.
Being a butter, shea tends to be thicker than the other ingredients, and depending on the type, may form more of a protective seal on top of the lips. So it has both emollient and occlusive properties.
I often call it my "matte lip balm," as the waxier shea butters will not leave your lips glossy or oily. I love to use this type of shea underneath lipsticks because it won't interfere with the finish, creates a barrier from irritants, and offsets dryness.
The key is to find one with a good texture, as lower-quality shea butter can be way too hard and crumbly, making it impossible to spread! (Now Foods, I'm talking about you.)
Best Shea Butter Lip Treatments
- LXMI Pure Nilotica Melt Nourishing Balm-to-Oil: I originally bought this as a face oil (hence the jar size), but they've now come out with a tube version that is perfect for your lips, and can be carried in your handbag! This one melts on contact, leaving a beautiful shine and eliminating the need for lip gloss.
- L'Occitane Mini Pure Shea Butter: If you're looking for a matte lip balm, this is for you! It has a thicker, semi-waxy texture (although still very spreadable) that is ideal under lipsticks.
- Institut Karité 100% Shea Butter: This one is somewhere in between—it's thick yet soft and imparts a slight sheen.
If you've been suffering from dry lips, I hope that one or more of these treatments finally does the trick!
In my opinion, it's all about eliminating possible irritants or allergens—yes, even forgoing lip colour for the time being—while you heal and nourish your lips with pure, healing oils and butters.
Less is always more. Since our lips don't have sebaceous glands like the rest of our face, they're not producing protective oils. So they're especially vulnerable to every little problem ingredient.
That's why I'm recommending you stick with a pure wax (lanolin), oil (squalane) or butter (shea butter) with nothing else added.
Let me know how it goes—and if you find any other great products for this issue!
Shop Editor's Picks
Have you tried any of these treatments for chapped lips?
What's your favourite lip balm?